superior court tucson superior court tucson

Industry. In a separate case last year, Clements was sentenced to life in prison for the 2014 death of 13-year-old Maribel Gonzalez. Jamie Donnelly covers breaking news for the Arizona Daily Star. The other family the statement referred to is that of Maribel Gonzalez. TUCSON, Ariz. (AP) A man already convicted of killing a Tucson teenager declined to take the stand and testify in his own defense Wednesday as closing arguments began in his second murder trial. The church helped to set up the "Isabel Celis Faith and Hope Center" for volunteers to aid in the search. Ray told the jury the old slides werent accurate, since TraX had undergone the update in 2019 to try to address gaps in coverage points. Physical evaluations, drug screening and extensive background checks may be conducted based on the requirements of the position. Pima County Attorney Laura Conover responded to Friday's mistrial in case against Christopher Clements, charged with killing 6-year-old Isabel Celis. Finally, the information contained on this website is not guaranteed to be up to date. Our thoughts tonight are with the Celis and Gonzalez families," said the statement Friday evening from Conover's office. FILE - This undated file photo released by the Tucson Police Department shows Christopher Matthew Clements. Their daughter was reported missing from her midtown Tucson home last Saturday morning. The Tucson Police Department, as well as other agencies, have searched a three-mile radius around her home. 3060 N. Swan Rd, Tucson, AZ 85712 Phone: (520) 325-4200 (Office), (520) 325-4224 (Fax) Specialties: Mediation - 50% (12 years) Arbitration - 15% (12 years) Licenses: Arizona - Active 1976 Experience: Mediator/ Attorney at Karp & Weiss PC 2010-present Judge of Superior Court at Arizona Superior Court 1985-2010 School: GEORGETOWN U Full Profile The system that brought snow to portions of southern Arizona overnight is moving to New Mexico. Changes to DC Superior eFiling as of October 31, 2022. The Court is committed to fairness, efficiency, accessibility, and exemplary customer service. State Bar of Arizona Commission on Judicial Conduct Court Vacancies City or town councils appoint their judges, except in Yuma, where municipal court judges are elected. Yuma County Superior Court, Arizona Protection Order Initiation & Notification Tool, Online Mediation for Parenting Time Disputes. The defense team referred to Isabels missing clothes, items family members had told police were her favorites, as a reason to suspect a family member was involved, most likely, the defense contends, her father. He ruled that Lake knew about the county's procedures for reviewing signatures long . Gov. GermanGreek Contact Star reporter Caitlin Schmidt at 573-4191 or cschmidt@tucson.com . Jury selection from a pool of nearly 100 potential jurors began Thursday, Feb. 9, 2023, in Pima County Superior Court with Christopher Clements' trial expected to start Tuesday and last 18 days. Sergio Celis previously testified he had arrived home that afternoon to find his dogs running loose in the street, after the door leading to their backyard was presumably opened. . Superior Court Address Administrative Office Suffolk County Courthouse, 3 Pemberton Square 13th Floor Boston, MA 02108 Directions Phone (617) 788-8130 Fax (617) 788-8137 Find a contact Contact the Superior Court Administrative Office News Locations Search this organization Notices & Alerts Hide Also, the law may vary from state-to-state or county-to-county, so that some information in this website may not be correct for your situation. SerbianSlovak Clerk of the Superior Court Email Physical Address: 2160 N. Congress Drive Suite 2200 Nogales, AZ 85621 Mailing Address: P.O. Box 1265 Nogales, AZ 85628 Phone: 520-375-7700 Fax: 520-375-7703 Staff Directory Christopher M. Clements, accused of killing Isabel Celis, 6, has now been charged with promoting prison contraband, a felony, while his murder, Cellular data shows the phone belonging to murder suspect Christopher Clements was near the Tucson home of Isabel Celis, 6, and also near the , Evidence from Christopher Clements' bank and phone records shows he also chose to eat lunch near the police command post that day, and had pho, Murder suspect Christopher Clements told police he was with a group at a Hooter's, then bowling, then home alone for hours the night Tucson ch, Christopher M. Clements, 41, a convicted sex offender, is on trial on charges of kidnapping and killing 6-year-old Isabel Celis, who went miss, The fracture likely injured the Tucson child's spinal cord, an expert witness for the prosecution said Friday in the trial of the man accused , The family members became emotional as they told jurors about the 6-year-old Tucson girl's disappearance.Christopher M. Clements, 41, is facin. Docket Number. CatalanChinese (Simplified) Business. Click here for more information about this change and Portal Frequently Asked Questions. Who does that? Jurors deadlocked in the trial of Clements, 41, on a charge of first-degree murder in the 2012 death of 6-year-old Isabel Celis, they told Pima County Superior Court Judge James Marner after two days of deliberations. Subscribe to stay connected to Tucson. State Bar of Arizona Isabel was reported missing from her bedroom the morning of April 21, 2012. How about someone who for this time period in between Isabels abduction and when shes found does searches (of her name) on his devices? Miller asked. Suspect in Celis killing accused of taking sharp pencil into jail, Collection: Read the latest on the trial of Christopher Clements, Lawmakers want to strip 19 cities' rights but Tucson is real target, Celebrity Las Vegas chefs opening Tucson restaurant, A bunch of photos of today's snow across Tucson , The highly anticipated Portillo's is now open in Tucson, 'Attainable' apartments coming to northwest Tucson, A big ol' guide to this weekend's Tucson Festival of Books, Watch: The most notable things Tommy Lloyd said after Arizona's heartbreaking loss to ASU, New game, entertainment center makes southwest Tucson a bigger draw, South Tucson motel sold to soup kitchen for housing, Tim Steller's column: Converting Tucson's big boxes, vast parking lots into housing tantalizes, 100 fun events happening in Tucson this March 2023 , Tucson lawmaker loses first bid to dump cities' rights, 'Extreme weather' closes parts of Interstates 17, 40 in Arizona, Tucson jury fails to reach verdict in murder case of Isabel Celis, 6, Jurors now deliberating whether Clements killed Isabel Celis, 6, Clements' phone was near child's home the day she disappeared, Suspect in Tucson child's slaying washed car the day she disappeared, Clements said he was alone hours the night Isabel Celis disappeared, 'Isabel Celis' searches found on computer of suspect in her killing, Isabel Celis, 6, suffered vertebral fracture in homicide, jury told, Isabel Celis' family testifies at trial of man accused in her death, Dad defends himself in Tucson trial of young daughter's alleged killer, Defense attorney tries to blame father of slain Isabel Celis, 6, Prosecutor: New trial, new jury ahead in slaying of Tucson child, Recapping Christopher Clements' trial in Tucson, Removal of golf course saguaros stirs controversy. Danielle Kamps Constant has been named as a new judge in Pima County Superior Court. The Arizona Superior Court in Pima County is comprised of 53 judicial officers that hear criminal, civil, family law, juvenile, and probate matters. 12-284, with increases approved by the Supreme Court as provided in the Arizona Code of Judicial Administration (ACJA) 3-404. You have permission to edit this article. They can also issue search warrants. Municipal court judges (magistrates) hear misdemeanor criminal traffic cases such as driving under the influence of alcohol, hit-and-run and reckless driving where no serious injuries occur. A felony conviction is an automatic bar to employment. The Clerk of the Superior Court maintains its own Human Resources. During the initial investigation, Tucson police asked Isabels mother, Becky Celis, to participate in a monitored phone call with her husband Sergio to try to uncover new details. Interpreters Human Resources, Volunteer If you have received notice for jury duty, please contact: Pima County Jury Commissioner's Office 110 W. Congress, Room 132 Tucson, AZ 85701 Phone: (520) 724-4222 Web site: Jury Duty | Official website of the City of Tucson Citation Number. Hanson said his questioning of Becky Celis about whether her husband was possibly involved in Isabels disappearance was pressing to get to the truth, but that there was never a formal investigation into Sergio Celis as a suspect. Fox said the lack of an answer to how entrance and exit had been made to the house was evidence enough, although not blatant. CzechDanish Celis played on the Diamondbacks team. PolishPortuguese Staff Login, Translate this Page: Superior Court Filing Fees The filing fee schedules offered through this webpage reflect the fees established in the Arizona Revised Statutes, A.R.S. Clements, a convicted sex offender with a long criminal record, was arrested in 2018 and indicted on 22 felony counts in the girls deaths. Applications are evaluated as received. Clements' defense attorneys argued to the jury that Sergio Celis, Isabels father, was to blame in her death, although he was never charged and testified he had nothing to do with it, and although Clements led authorities to Isabels remains in a desert area five years after she went missing. All hallways and doorways that have public access are ADA compliant. In larger cities, the judges may also have court administrators. Chinese (Traditional)Croatian Volunteers create door hangers that have information to help them find missing girl, Isabel Celis, at a command post at Abbie Loveland Tuller School on June 1, 2012. Fax: (928) 817-4044 TUCSON, Ariz. (AP) A mistrial was declared after a jury in southern Arizona was unable to reach a verdict on a murder charge against a man accused of killing a 6-year-old girl. Kessler also asked Hanson about his report, in which he said Sergio was sweating profusely and he wasnt sure why. Miller projected a photo of a young Hispanic girl onto a wall-sized television screen. Before closing arguments, the defense called witnesses Tuesday and Wednesday, including a former Tucson police detective. They share jurisdiction with justice courts over violations of state law committed within their city or town limits. HindiHungarian Misdemeanor convictions are reviewed on a case by case basis and may be a bar to employment in some circumstances. The jury of eight men and four women began deliberating Thursday morning in Superior Court. D.C. Superior Court case search has moved to Odyssey Portal for the following case types (Phase 1): Please click on the below search button to take you to the new Odyssey Portal. Ray told jurors that Clements phone had been in the area of the Celis house twice on April 13, 2012. Jury selection from a pool of nearly 100 potential jurors began Thursday, Feb. 9, 2023, in Pima County Superior Court with Christopher Clements' trial expected to start Tuesday and last 18 days. Self-Service Center A judge declared a mistrial Friday afternoon in Christopher Clements' trial on a first-degree murder charge in the child's 2012 death. 2023 Arizona Supreme Court. El Centro de Autoservicio, Contact Us Then, reminding them of testimony about Clements behavior, she added: How about someone who plants a note in their front yard with the name Isabel Celis hidden under a rock? When Kessler asked her if they considered the front door to the home a potential point of entry, she said Tucson police had considered every access point into and out of that home.. PolishPortuguese He told the jury it was difficult to enter the room without knowing what was on the other side of the window. RomanianRussian In addition, Constant serves as a member of the advisory board of the Salvation Army of Southern Arizona and volunteers for pro bono cases through her firm. Virtual interviews are available upon request. Catch up here on what's happened so far. Share & Bookmark, Press Enter to show all options, press Tab go to next option, Engineering Department / Flood Control District, Engineering Department/Flood Control District-About Us, Special Assessments Improvement Districts, Maintenance Connection (For YC Employees Only), Flu Prevention and Vaccination Information. Tucson Police Chief Chris Magnus, Pima County Attorney Barbara LaWall and Pima County Sheriff Mark Napier at a press conference in Tucson on Sept. 15, 2018. to announce the indictment of Christopher Matthew Clements in connection with the deaths of Isabel Cells and Maribel Gonzalez. Some cities do not require municipal court judges to be attorneys. The Superior Court urges anyone contacted by potential scammers to immediately call the Jury Commissioner's Office (520) 724-4222, to verify whether a jury summons is in effect. Notices Archive. Doug Ducey announced the appointment of a. You may review a hard copy of the Arizona Superior Court in Pima County Equal Employment Opportunity Report (EEOP) at the reception desk on the 9th floor of the Superior Court, or by clicking on the page: Equal Employment Opportunity Report (EEOP) on the left. Tucson City Court Marijuana Expungement Forms The Arizona Supreme Court has adopted petition forms and instructions for people to use to petition the court for an expungement order. This website has been prepared for general information purposes only. Careers Tucson, AZ. Photos of murder victim Maribel Gonzalez on display during a press conference held by Homicide Survivors, Inc. on April 12, 2016. Human Resources $52,104 to $57,990 Yearly. Yuma County Superior Court The Judicial Branch of Arizona in Maricopa County - Court Calendars and Public Proceedings View today's criminal and civil department calendars View calendars or search now Administrative Order 2022-113 In-person and Remote Hearings Read More Case Search Today's Hearings Court Forms Jury Adult Probation Public Information Clements said he had nothing to do with Celis death and he only knew the location of the body, according to authorities. His month-long trial started on February 14. GermanGreek Becky and Sergio Celis pray during a the concert at Catalina United Methodist Church on May 6, 2012. But thats not what the jury instructions (from the judge) tell you to do.. Arizona Revised Statutes Tucson Police officers search the Los Reales landfill as part of the search for 6 year-old Isabel Celis on April 23, 2012. BelarusianBulgarian The Clerk of the Superior Court makes no warranty of any kind with respect to data or documents accessed, unless an original document with the Clerk of the Court filing stamp can be produced to substantiate proof of filing or error. NorwegianPersian Volunteer-AmeriCorps, Helpful Links Subscribe to stay connected to Tucson. Contact Star reporter Caitlin Schmidt at 573-4191 or cschmidt@tucson.com. SlovenianSpanish Volunteer-CASA During her rebuttal, Miller told the jurors that Kessler was inviting them to do what police did in 2012 and look at the family. Subscribe to our Daily Headlines newsletter. Clements, a convicted sex offender, has already been sentenced to natural life in prison in connection with 13-year-old Maribel Gonzalezs 2014 murder, and another 17 years for her kidnapping, which will be served consecutively. She was reported missing June 3 and listed as a runaway on June 4. View job description, responsibilities and qualifications. Superior Court. Applications are evaluated as received. Arizona Superior Court in Pima County. Prosecutors say he became a suspect when he led investigators to the location of her remains in 2017, in return for authorities dropping unrelated charges against him. FinnishFrench A detective previously identified the photo, along with several others found on Clements devices, as being taken in Tucson. CatalanChinese (Simplified) In this Series NorwegianPersian Docket numbers are 8 - 10 digits. Court records may be destroyed in accordance with approved minimum retention and disposition schedules. SlovenianSpanish FILE - This photo released by the Tucson Police Department on Sept. 15, 2018, shows Christopher Clements. Azerbaijani ALPHABasque ALPHA Christopher M. Clements faces charges of kidnapping and first-degree murder in the 2012 killing of then 6-year-old Isabel Celis. National Center for State Courts We offer a competitive benefits package to benefits eligible employees, which includes . Miller told the jury things that seemed like coincidence were circumstantial evidence of Clements guilt. Earlier in the day, Clements lawyers continued their questioning of the states 25th and final witness, cell phone tracking expert Sy Ray. A jury that got the case late Wednesday afternoon deliberated for 5 1/2 hours Thursday and will resume Friday morning. Superior Court Judge James Marner denied the defense motion, saying he found substantial circumstantial and direct evidence to support the charges against Clements. Christopher M. Clements faces charges of kidnapping and first-degree murder in the 2012 killing of then 6-year-old Isabel Celis. Christopher Clements is facing first-degree murder, kidnapping and other felony charges in the death of 6-year-old Isabel Celis, who was reported missing from her bedroom in her parents home in April 2012. Abrian Gonzalez, father of Maribel Victoria Gonzalez (background photo), talks about his daughter while at Homicide Survivors in June, 2014. "At this point, a new trial date will be ordered, and a new jury will have to be chosen to decide the matter. The El Presidio parking garage is accessible from Pennington Street on the south side or Alameda Street on the north side. GalicianGeorgian ALPHA TUCSON, Ariz. (AP) A mistrial was declared after a jury in southern Arizona was unable to reach a verdict on a murder charge against a man accused of killing a 6-year-old girl. Holly Salgado and Tara Alexander stand near a truck with a picture of Isabel Celis near the police command post near Craycroft and Broadway on April 22, 2012. Constant also practices civil litigation with an emphasis on eminent domain and release estate litigation. TraX which was created by Ray and has since been sold to more than 650 law enforcement agencies across the country allows investigators to visualize and analyze call detail records and third-party device location information. Court Defendant Search | Official website of the City of Tucson Court Defendant Search If your case does not appear, please either contact Court directly (520) 791-4216 or please file a Public Record Request with the Courts. Defense attorneys pointed to a lack of physical evidence, with no fingerprints or DNA connecting Clements to Isabels disappearance or death. DutchEnglish Catch up here on what's happened so far. Azerbaijani ALPHABasque ALPHA JapaneseKorean These forms should not be filed before the July 12, 2021 effective date. She allegedly expressed previous doubts Clements was guilty, but the jury did not hear about that. Becky Celis holds back tears as she speaks to reporters at the Christian Faith Fellowship church at 5601 E. Broadway, where volunteers set up the "Isabel Celis Faith and Hope Center" for volunteers to aid in the search of daughter Isabel Celis in July, 2012. Gonzalez disappeared while walking to a friends house in June 2014 and authorities said her body was found days later in a remote desert area. MalayMaltese The defendant was the person who revealed Isas remains to the FBI, Ward said in his response to the motion. Clements defense team filed a motion Tuesday to dismiss the charges against him, arguing there is no physical evidence tying Clements to Isabels disappearance. Hanson said it was possible his note about Sergio Celis sweating was during the portion of his interview where he recreated the events after Isabels disappearance, recalling that Sergio had said at the time, just taking me back there is bringing it all up.. All Rights Reserved. Isabel's father, mother and brother testified about the morning in April 2012 that she went missing from her Tucson bedroom. Get the latest in local public safety news with this weekly email. He said that while he couldnt remember the specific model of phone Sergio Celis had been using, his report indicated it was capable of holding large amounts of data.. They DO NOT hear civil lawsuits between citizens. She also noted Isabels open bedroom window and the screen that was bent and propped up against the house. Cash, cashier check, personal check, credit card, money orders, Pima County Superior Courthouse ADA Accessibility Information, New Years Day; Martin Luther King Jr. Day; President's Day; Memorial Day; Independence Day; Labor Day; Veteran's Day; Thanksgiving; Day after Thanksgiving; Christmas Day; New Year's Eve. City of Tucson residents may also file a local Tucson Police Department report at any TPD substation, Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., or by calling . We may not know exactly how he got Isabel Celis out of her window that morning, but what we do know over the last two-and-a-half weeks is that the person responsible is Christopher Clements., Defense attorney Eric Kessler told the jury this is one of the worst cases hes ever tried, calling it tragic and horrible.. Careers FinnishFrench Political Cartoons View All 902 Images She also handles government agency defense, insurance defense, employment, family law matters and serves as a judge pro tem for the superior court, the news release said. Career Opportunities Rick Wiley / Arizona Daily Star CzechDanish All Rights Reserved. He questioned retired Tucson police detective Bill Hanson, who became involved in the investigation two days after Isabels disappearance. Clements previously told police he was sleeping in on the morning of April 21, 2012 and didnt start his day until around 11 a.m., but Ray testified that Clements phone was in the recovery area from 9:20 to 10:17 a.m. Kessler questioned Ray about the coverage area of the cell phone tower near the recovery site, off Avra Valley and Trico Roads, that picked up Clements phone the morning Isabel went missing. She was a civil litigator at Gust Rosenfeld and a prosecutor at the Pima County Attorneys Office, the news release said. Posted: January 16, 2023. Her case went unsolved and Clements was not identified as a suspect until March 2017, when he led investigators to her remains in exchange for the dropping of unrelated charges. A man already convicted of killing a Tucson teenager in 2012 now is facing another murder trial, this one involving a 6-year-old girl. A man already convicted of killing a Tucson teenager in 2012 now is facing another murder trial, this one involving a 6-year-old girl. The 13-year-old Tucson girl was killed in 2014 by Clements, according to a separate jury's verdict last year in a successful prosecution by Conover's office against the convicted sex offender. Legal Reference & Links Handicapped parking spaces are located on all four corners on all levels (A, B and C) of the El Presidio parking garage, next to the elevators. Courtesy of the Office of the Governor Jamie Donnelly Arizona Gov. Full-time employees of government organizations may be able to receive student loan forgiveness under the Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program. Arizona Gov. Welcome to the Pima County Consolidated Justice Court Website. El Centro de Autoservicio, Contact Us Yuma, AZ 85364, Main: (928) 817-4083 When the Celis family went to bed on the night of April 20, 2012, they had no way of knowing the unbelievable nightmare they would wake up to the next morning, Deputy Pima County Attorney Tracy Miller told the jury. Commission on Judicial Conduct Municipal Court Governance Roles and Responsibilities, Open, Close,Consolidate, Co-Locate, and Bifurcate Courts. On Feb. 7, days before his trial in Isabels death began, Christopher M. Clements was found to have a sharpened pencil while being confined in a correctional facility or while being lawfully transported or moved incident to correctional facility, according to court documents. Danielle Kamps Constant has been named as a new judge in Pima County Superior Court. Constant is the managing partner of the Jennings Strouss and Salmon Tucson office and has been with the firm since 2017, the news release said. IcelandicIndonesian The Arizona Judicial Branch is pleased to offer Public Access to Court Case Information, a valuable online service providing a resource for information about court cases from 177 out of 184 courts in Arizona. Clements, a convicted sex . EstonianFilipino People placing their candles at the bottom of a large poster of Isabel near the end of the candlelight vigil in the parking lot near the police command post near Craycroft and Broadway in honor of Isabel Celis on April 22, 2012. Becky Celis pauses as she asks for the return of her daughter Isabel, 6, as her husband Sergio stands next to her at a volunteer center close to their home on April 25, 2012. Site Map The Diamondbacks, a coach-pitch baseball team, stand in a moment of silence after their game at Freedom Park for Isabel Celis, the six-year-old girl reported missing, April 24, 2012. A subscription helps you access more of the local stories that keep you connected to the community. Deputy Pima County Attorney Jonathan Mosher, left, at the arraignment for Christopher Clements in Pima County Superior Court in Tucson on Sept. 25, 2018. Trial begins for Christopher M. Clement, charged with kidnapping and first-degree murder in Tucson girl's 2012 abduction and killing. The morning Isabel was discovered missing from her bedroom, Clements phone was again in the area of her home, then later traveled to a desert area in Marana where Isabels remains were later discovered, according to data provided by AT&T, Ray said. Tucson, AZ 85701-1317 A different Pima County Superior Court jury heard Clements murder trial involving Celis. Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device. AfrikaansAlbanian Self-driving truck developerTuSimplehas more room to grow in Tucson after christening a building on East Old Vail Road. Career Opportunities The superior court is the state's general jurisdiction court. Clements defense team also called another police detective involved in the initial investigation. 9th Floor OPEN UNTIL FILLED at both Superior Court and Juvenile Court locations. Municipal courts have criminal jurisdiction over misdemeanor crimes and petty offenses committed in their city or town. Quick Defendant Public Search. Hanson said he documented it simply because it was something I noticed.. Haitian Creole ALPHAHebrew He declared a mistrial. The trial is set to resume Wednesday at 10:30 a.m. in Pima County Superior Court. LithuanianMacedonian UkrainianUrdu ALPHA Tucson, AZ. Clements said he had nothing to do with Celis death and he only knew the location of the body, according to authorities. Posted: January 22, 2023. Kessler asked Fox what evidence of an intruder they found during the initial investigation, as he cited the lack of fingerprints and physical evidence tying anyone to Isabels abduction. Suite E TUCSON (KVOA) The Pima County Clerk of Court's Office is facing an independent investigation into its IT department after the Arizona Supreme Court issued an administrative order. Isabel was reported missing from her bedroom in her parents home in Tucson in April 2012. Legal advice is dependent upon the specific circumstances of each situation. -- Select language -- SerbianSlovak AfrikaansAlbanian The person who abducted and murdered Isabel Celis.. Members of the Diamondbacks little league team release their balloons during a vigil at Freedom Park for Isabel Celis, the six-year-old girl reported missing since Saturday morning on April 24, 2012. Public Access to the Judicial Records of the State of Arizona . Prosecutors told jurors the circumstantial evidence was "overwhelming," including internet searches on Clements computer, tracking records showing his cell phone locations, and the fact he knew where her body was. Therefore, the information contained in this website cannot replace the advice of competent legal counsel licensed in your jurisdiction. To secure a conviction of first-degree murder, the state must prove the crime was either premeditated or considered felony murder.. ThaiTurkish The image of Isabel, 6, on the back of her father's shirt as he gets a hug after the parents' first public appearance at a volunteer center close to their home on April 25, 2012. The first-degree murder case against Christopher Clements has now gone to the jury in the Tucson child's 2012 death. Clerk of the Superior Court, Pima County Tucson, AZ 85713 (Las Vistas area) +2 locations From $15.75 an hour Full-time Monday to Friday + 1 Requirements English Work Authorization Pretrial Services Specialist Pima County Superior Court 3.8 Tucson, AZ 85701 $21.57 - $26.75 an hour Full-time 8 hour shift Responsive employer